Critique Guidelines

Chenyang Lu

---

Submission

• Due at 1 pm on the due date.
• Critiques must be submitted in time. A one-time late submission will be accepted.
• Submit on Canvas.

---

Guidelines

• About half a page of ideas/comments - not complete essays.
• We want to hear your own thoughts. Do not simply summarize the paper.
• Identify open issues and limitations of the paper (think of yourself as a reviewer or a researcher on the same subject).

---

Sample Questions

• Are the assumptions reasonable and realistic?
• Is the solution practical?
• Any technical errors and limitations?
• Any problems with the experiments?
• Do the results support the claims?
• Any way to improve the work?
• How does the work relate to other topics previously covered in class?

---