Submission
Due10 a.m. on the due date
SubmitThrough Canvas
Late submissionOne late submission will be accepted
What to write
- Aim for about half a page of ideas and comments. A complete essay is not expected.
- Share your own analysis instead of simply summarizing the paper.
- Identify open questions and limitations. Consider the paper as a reviewer or a researcher working in the same area.
Questions to consider
Assess the approach
- Are the assumptions reasonable and realistic?
- Is the solution practical?
- Are there technical errors or limitations?
- How could the work be improved?
Evaluate the evidence
- Are there problems with the experiments?
- Do the results support the paper’s claims?
- How does the work relate to topics covered earlier in class?
Use these questions to guide your own analysis of the paper.