Critique Guidelines
Prof. Chenyang Lu
Submission
- Due
at 10am on the due date. Hard
deadline (no late critique will be
accepted).
- Plain
text in the body of your message. No attachment unless you
have to use figures.
- E-mail TA with subject:
[Critique #number] last name,
first name. For example, [Critique #1] Hackmann, Greg.
Critique
the Paper
About half a page
of ideas/comments - not complete essays.
We want
to hear your own thoughts. Do not simply summarize the paper.
Identify open
issues and limitations of the paper (think of yourself as a reviewer or a researcher on the same subject).
- Are
the
assumptions reasonable and realistic?
- Is
the solution practical?
- Any
technical
errors and limitations?
- Any
problems with the experimentation?
- Do
the results
support the claims?
- Any
ways to improve the work?
- How
does the work relate to the other topics previously
covered in class?